Year | Name | Wgt | Place | Year | Name | Wgt | Place |
1977 | Jack Bertsch | 185 | 4th | 2003 | Adam Myers | 152 | Qualifier |
1980 | Lynn Fiechter | 112 | 2nd | 2004 | Tyson Bercot | 103 | Qualifier |
1981 | Mike Gremaux | 126 | 4th |  | Dustin Mitchel | 189 | 4th |
| Leroy Striker | 132 | 4th | | Josh Stetler | 275 | Qualifier |
1982 | Jim Jesionowski | 185 | Qualifier | 2005 | Tyson Bercot | 112 | 3rd |
1983 | Troy Roe | 105 | Qualifier | 2006 | Tyson Bercot | 112 | Qualifier |
| Ray Ashley | 119 | Qualifier | | Vince McAfee | 152 | 6th |
1984 | Lonnie Chamberlain | 98 | Qualifier | 2007 | Ethan Fiechter | 103 | Qualifier |
| Troy Roe | 105 | 4th | | Tyson Bercot | 125 | Qualifier |
| Ray Ashley | 119 | 2nd | | Brandon Gaskill | 160 | Qualifier |
1985 | Lonnie Chamberlain | 98 | Qualifier | 2008 | Ethan Fiechter | 119 | Qualifier |
| Troy Roe | 105 | CHAMPION | 2009 | Jarod Schwartz | 130 | Qualifier |
| Gregg Snyder | 138 | Qualifier | | Trey Schultz | 171 | 8th |
1986 | Troy Roe | 105 | 5th | 2010 | Zeke Schultz | 135 | Qualifier |
| Gregg Snyder | 138 | 4th | 2011 | Cody Walburn | 112 | Qualifier |
| Jeff McCullough | 155 | 4th | | Derek Roe | 119 | Qualifier |
1987 | Mark Griffiths | 105 | Qualifier | | Jarod Schwartz | 152 | Qualifier |
| Shane Reynolds | 112 | Qualifier | 2012 | Chantz Luginbill | 160 | Qualifier |
1988 | Jim Marbaugh | 130 | 3rd | 2013 | Cody Walburn | 126 | Qualifier |
| Jeff Carroll | 189 | Qualifier | | Kaine Luginbill | 160 | Qualifier |
1989 | Joe Hurst | 119 | Qualifier | | Ben Pfister | 182 | Qualifier |
| Brent Byerly | 135 | Qualifier | 2014 | Derek Ellinger | 138 | Qualifier |
| Jim Marbaugh | 145 | 3rd | | Kaine Luginbill | 170 | Qualifier |
| Todd Yoder | 160 | Qualifier | 2015 | Anthony Mosser | 113 | Qualifier |
| Brian Heyerly | 171 | Qualifier | | Kaine Luginbill | 170 | 4th |
| Matt Birch | 189 | Qualifier | 2016 | Hunter Bates | 152 | 8th |
1990 | Denny Schwartz | 112 | Qualifier | 2017 | Anthony Mosser | 132 | Qualifier |
| Mark Griffiths | 125 | 2nd | | Logan Macklin | 138 | Qualifier |
| Trent Reynolds | 130 | Qualifier | 2018 | Logan Mosser | 120 | Qualifier |
| Todd Yoder | 171 | 4th | | Chandler Schumm | 220 | Qualifier |
1991 | Denny Schwartz | 119 | Qualifier | 2019 | Logan Mosser | 132 | Qualifier |
1992 | Denny Schwartz | 119 | 4th | | Logan Macklin | 145 | 5th |
| Matt Liter | 130 | 5th | 2020 | Alex Currie | 145 | 7th |
1993 | Tony Currie | 140 | Qualifier | 2021 | Logan Uhlman | 126 | Qualifier |
1994 | Tony Currie | 145 | 2nd | | Alex Currie | 152 | Qualifier |
| Ryan Wolfe | 189 | 5th | | Blake Heyerly | 189 | 8th |
1995 | Tony Currie | 151 | 3rd | 2022 | Gavin Cook | 126 | Qualifier |
| Ryan Wolfe | 215 | 5th | | Logan Uhlman | 132 | 8th |
1996 | Andy Bertsch | 135 | 2nd | | Alex Currie | 152 | Qualifier |
| Brian Werst | 275 | Qualifier | | Blake Heyerly | 220 | 5th |
1997 | Andy Bertsch | 135 | 3rd | 2023 | Logan Uhlman | 138 | Qualifier |
| Eric Hunter | 145 | 4th | | Zac Wurm | 285 | Qualifier |
1999 | Adam McAfee | 140 | Qualifier | 2025 | Dylan Ogg | 138 | Qualifier |
| Craig Beer | 152 | Qualifier | | Brason Schortgen | 150 | Qualifier |
2000 | Ryan Landis | 130 | Qualifier | | Maverick Dubach | 157 | 8th |
2001 | Landon Genth | 103 | Qualifier | 2026 | Dylan Ogg | 150 | 4th |
| Adam Myers | 145 | Qualifier | | Brason Schortgen | 165 | 5th |
2002 | Landon Genth | 112 | Qualifier | | | | |